Stanford Prison Experiment

The Stanford Prison Experiment is well-known to students of psychology courses at universities and high schools. The Stanford Prison Experiment was conducted in 1971 by the U.S. Navy to examine the causes of conflict between guards in military prisons. Dr. Philip Zimbardo’s team selected 24 Stanford male students to be his subjects and divided them into guards or prisoners. Zimbardo made a prison out of the basement of one student hall. He watched as his subjects became passive while the guards displayed authority through sometimes cruel psychological torture. Zimbardo stopped the experiment after the 2-week period had ended. This was primarily because of the objections from his fiancee. She felt Zimbardo was an unhealthy participant in his investigation.

This documentary could be fascinating since some experiments are available on film. The Stanford Prison Experiment is a dramatization. It is not proper to Zimbardo’s original work. Instead of focusing on prisoner abuse, it removes the experiment from psychological theories and details. One guard who believes he’s Strother Martin from “Cool Hand Luke” sexually abuses prisoners. Prisoners take the abuse and rebel once or twice before they become passive. Zimbardo stares at the TV, doing nothing, while his guards violate the terms of the contract everyone signed. Repeat ad nauseum.

These scenes are meant to shock viewers, but they didn’t work for me because I didn’t care. The entire film is reduced to a Dead Teenager movie, whose slasher only roughs them up. The film refers to prisoners by numbers to remove their identities. The film only lets us know the subject after brief sketches. Thus, we are unable and unwilling to make any connection with them. Despite all the efforts of actors from both sides of the law, the film is essentially clinical in portraying the subject. It strikes the same note for more than 2 hours, despite the best efforts of both actors. It’s not a prison, but a group of privileged children playing dress up for $15 daily. A priest Zimbardo hired as a prison chaplain tells the doctor that it’s “good that these privileged children experience prison life.” The priest’s comment almost seems to be the reason for these tests.

The film insists that no one in the experiment sustained “long-term psychological damage” after the abrupt cancellation. Someone who has dealt with the harsh realities of prison life would be relieved to know that these young men were not scared. The Stanford Prison Experiment’s best scene features an actual prisoner. It shows how I wouldn’t say I like how the film uses emotion and details to exploitative shocks. The fantastic Nelsan plays Jesse (last seen on “Get Up“), an ex-con brought in to testify at their proceedings by Zimbardo. Jesse verbally shatters the explanations of parolees at a mock parole board hearing by ripping into them. Jesse tells the inmate that he was reliving his parole board treatment after he sent him back to his cell.

Zimbardo is shocked when Jesse tells Zimbardo that he is playing the role of his tormentor. Jesse’s revelation and the psychological toll it causes on him are far more potent than in any other film. It would have been more effective if the film spent more time with Strother Martin-wannabe and his thoughts than just chasing him out for sadism. Zimbardo is reduced to a megalomaniac who does not know what he’s doing. His research seems haphazard and unprofessional. The film portrays him as the greatest villain, watching the guards attack the prisoners (a clear violation of the rules). He confronts anyone who doubts his authority and methods, and at one point, he sits absurdly in a hallway as a low-rent Charles Brannon, hoping for the return to his subject. In the actual case, Zimbardo moves the prison to an unknown location. However, he intends to “feminize” the prisoners with “dresses” that hide their genitalia barely, “The Stanford Prison Experiment” suggests that Zimbardo was only trying to stop the experiment when his guards forced them into a gay sex pantomime.

The movie suggests that violence and hog-tying were acceptable, but not all gay stuff. Billy Crudup should be awarded a medal for trying to bring life into his character. Ezra Miller and Olivia Thirlby also deserve a medal. They are ruined by poor scripts, horror-movie-style music, and dramatizations that only make the viewer feel superior. Movies like “Compliance” are disgusting to me. They pretend to be profoundly describing their situations, but, in reality, they are cynically manipulative garbage designed to make viewers feel superior. This was the goal of the Stanford Prison Experiment. The movie is merely trying to disturb superficially, and it could be more successful at this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *