She was unable to handle it. She spiraled into addiction while her star rose to dizzying heights. She died four years ago from alcohol poisoning. Asif Kapadia, the director, wants to know the story of the retro-jazz singer/singer who died at the mythical age of 27. There were so many people watching.
The smoky-voiced singer’s short life and inevitable death seemed less like a train wreck than a complete derailment that was meticulously documented for tabloid pleasure. Kapadia, best known for his 2010 Formula One documentary, “Senna,” has a compelling and sympathetic portrait of the chanteuse. He takes a lot of people to task for her: the paparazzi, comics, and even the comedians who kept yelling at her about her eating disorders and substance abuse while also announcing her six Grammy nominations. And finally, there were the fans who adored the rawness of her songs, like “Rehab,” and demanded more, even though Winehouse had made it clear that those songs were not based on her actual life.
Chris King, an editor, assists Winehouse in combining new interviews with archive footage from Winehouse’s childhood, cross-career performances, and paparazzi run-ins. Winehouse also writes her autobiographical lyrics onscreen, adding extra power and a sense that there is imminent doom to critical moments in Winehouse’s life.
Kapadia managed to interview Janis Winehouse and Mitch Winehouse. He also interviewed Juliette Ashby, Lauren Gilbert, Blake Fielder-Civil, and producers Salaam Remi and Mark Ronson. Kapadia is a great listener and supporter of Tony Bennett and Yasiin bey (aka Mos Def).
Camcorder footage shows a 14-year-old Winehouse singing “Happy Birthday” in her distinctive voice. This contrasts with the starving singer who has achieved worldwide fame, which she doesn’t deserve, but which the documentary suggests that others need.
The film traces the perfect storm of bad relationships that led to Winehouse’s demise. It also includes the ineffectual mother who dismisses her daughter’s bulimia as a temporary condition, the absent father who once told Winehouse she didn’t require rehab and hired a crew to help her dry out in private. And the toxic relationship with her husband, who introduced her to hard drug use and inspired her acclaimed breakup album, “Back to Black.”
Unflinching, but not heartless or sensational. Amy even challenges the standard view that Winehouse’s signature voice was silenced as the most tragic aspect of her story.
As Ashby recalls the sober singer calling out after she won five Grammys to complain that “this is so boring without drugs,” Kapadia reminds viewers of what tabloid headlines, late-show jokes, and late-show gags failed to mention: Amy Winehouse was a person and those who loved her couldn’t change the channel or turn the page as she died.