The supernatural domestic abuse drama Sinister 2 is a mashup of two distinct narratives. Each story is unique, but neither one is better than the other. Both the film’s main demonic possession/ghost story and its tragic domestic drama subplot can be seen as extensions of one another. It is so bizarre that you want them to be better. Ciaran Foy (“Ziadel“) and Scott Derrickson, co-writers, do more than many horror films. Still, they fail to add anything new or thought-provoking to the story about the cyclical/inherited natures of victim/bully roles. Although the filmmakers have the right ideas, they must learn how to make them happen. This makes the film’s formulaic characters, and cheap jump scares even more disappointing. “Sinister 2,” while close to being a great movie, is ten times more bad than good.
“Sinister 2” begins on the wrong foot, in a Catholic church’s confessional box. The ghostly, unnamed former deputy sheriff (Tangerine’s James Ransone) wants to share his burden. He must stop Bughuul from abducting more children. Ransone’s ex-cop, a Catholic priest, does the intelligent thing and dismisses Ransone. This leads Ransone’s haunted ex to attempt to stop Bughuul from abducting more children.
Courtney’s story with her children is easily the best half of “Sinister 2” since it is most clearly about human protagonists. Ransone, the character of Courtney, cozies up with Dylan while Zach and Zach, who were once a close-knit couple, start making late-night visits to their basement. There, Dylan and Zach watch snuff movies starring their children’s families. Fleeing her abusive husband, Clint (Lea Coco), Courtney has inadvertently moved her and her boys to an abandoned farmhouse haunted by Bughuul’s victims. Dylan is not trying to escape from the nightmares of his friends, but he is a pint-sized survivor. Here’s “Sinister 2”, the part that the film doesn’t focus on: Childhood fears of being abused by a father who isn’t caring and then unwittingly left behind by a mother who is intelligent but not omniscient.
Cargill and Derrickson tentatively explore this last angle. Dylan even directly blames Courtney for failing to stop Clint. Bughuul’s show is “Sinister 2”, for the most part. It’s a shame because Bughuul does not seem an extension or complement to Dylan, Zach, and Courtney’s family struggles. Bughuul, a fright-mask-and-tuxedo-wearing demon better known as “The Boogeyman,” gets children to kill their families and film their murder sprees. He then abducted the children he tricked into murdering them.
The anti-familial instinct looks intriguing at first glance. It is a commentary on passively receiving violent art vs. actively creating it. Zach and Dylan are not both affected by horror films. However, if they make one of Bughuul’s snuff movies, they are transported into the film, becoming Bughuul’s victim. Ransone, a stereotypically anxious egghead scientist, explains that this is an “aesthetic appreciation for violence,” one of many ways Bughuul’s victims ostensibly honor him.
It becomes apparent that there is no direct connection between snuff movies/voyeurism, domestic abuse/post-divorce survivor’s guilt, and snuff film/voyeurism. It is easy to feel like the film has been made from rote and unimaginative material. Bughuul appears everywhere, even on a laptop monitor. In a barnyard hallway! In a bedroom closet, An old CB radio! – They get tiresome quickly since they are a monotonous and superficial way to get viewers out of their chairs. The graphic scenes of violence include images of people being burned alive on crucifixes and eaten by hungry rats.
In several scenes, Ransone’s character also says something funny, but it feels more like a joke-place-holder line. For example, he talks to the priest about never knowing if he will receive confession or any other sacrament from his church. Ransone’s facial tics (including furrowed eyebrows and pursed lips) seem even more irritating because they compensate for his lack of character definition. Ransone’s performance, however, could be better because the material he’s working with is just as cruel to him as Clint was to his sons. Although “Sinister 2” is ambitious, its best ideas, as expressed, are dumb, repetitive, unmoving, and inarticulate.