Near the end, Aunt Elizabeth ( Diane Kruger) tells her niece Katie Amanda Seyfried, with a weary look that can only have been cultivated through a life filled with disappointments, “men can survive without love, but not us women.”
The scene’s timing and framing suggest that we consider this at least one of the film’s thesis. It’s a strange story, as the film shifts between two timelines seamlessly.
The first is when Jake Davis ( Russell Crowe), a Pulitzer-winning novelist, dies in a car accident. He was driving and was arguing with his wife about years-old infidelity. Their young daughter Katie, played skillfully by Kylie Rogers, was in the backseat. Jake was hospitalized with trauma-related injuries and depression. Katie is placed with her aunt Elizabeth, her mother’s sister, and Uncle William ( Bruce Greenwood). Katie stays with them for seven months. Elizabeth and William inform Jake that they would prefer to adopt Katie and doubt that he can adequately care for her. You might be able to guess that they also have other motives.
The rest of the movie follows that line and cuts between the history and thirty-something Katie, now a Ph.D. student in psychology and working with Lucy ( Quvenzhane Wallace), a young girl who hasn’t spoken since her mother’s death. Katie also uses alcohol to self-medicate, hooking up at bars and bathrooms with men, something she says her therapist helped her feel “something.” (She is a budding psychologist, and she has emotional attachment issues, which is ironic. Katie then meets Cameron ( Aaron Paul), a man who idolizes her father but is a loving, long-suffering boyfriend. Katie is afraid of commitment, so she tries to drive him away. Will love triumph?
“Fathers and Daughters,” despite its title, is focused on one father and one girl. It also focuses on one idea: how your childhood experiences will influence your adult relationships and actions. It’s not an unusual idea. John Mayer has written about it. But, then, “Fathers and Daughters” is essentially predictable. Each plot point is predictable. As soon as Jake enters an institution, you can tell he will have difficulty keeping Katie there once he leaves. Like Katie’s actions to exorcise a demon when she meets a boy at school, you also know that it is a predictable plot point. The only thing surprising about the movie is that William (and Elizabeth) aren’t fatherless. The film’s big scenes signal hard through swelling music and self-consciously meaning one-liners that you are meant to feel here.
Sometimes you don’t. Melodrama can be good if the actors are skilled, and “Fathers and Daughters” are brimming with acting talent. Crowe and Rogers’ father-daughter chemistry feels natural, whether hugging or fighting. Seyfried’s expressive performance transforms an appearance that seemed borrowed from a Lifetime potboiler into something more humane. Brad Desch’s screenplay “Fathers and Daughters,” which was published in 2012 on the Black List, was directed by Gabriele Puccini (“7 Pounds” and “The Pursuit of Happiness”), who had extensive experience working with such material. It is beautifully shot and styled. It is beautiful to look at.
This brings us back to Aunt Elizabeth’s assertion that men don’t need love to be happy but that women do. “Fathers and Daughters” strongly suggests that the latter is true. Katie’s promiscuity slowly kills her, but the former is not. Cameron and Jake refuse to live apart from their love. Although you could argue Elizabeth is wrong, the statement hangs in the air. It’s like Elizabeth was saying something that’s not true. It feels like an Oscar-bait movie that is trying too hard. In some ways, that’s the reason it’s so watchable. Even in a film with mediocre actors, you can still see some great performances. It will be a great combination of “Fathers and Daughters,” a bottle of wine, and a friend on rainy nights.